Does Rental Income Count Toward Your Coast FIRE Number? It Shrinks It
Rental income does not add to your Coast FIRE number. It subtracts from the spending your portfolio has to cover, which shrinks the number. $15,000 a year in net rental income cuts roughly $375,000 off a 4% FIRE target, and about $111,000 off what you need saved today at 35.
The short answer is yes, count it, but count it on the spending side, not the asset side. Your FIRE number is your annual retirement spending divided by your withdrawal rate. Rental income reduces the spending your portfolio has to cover. With $60,000 of annual spending and $15,000 of net rental income, the portfolio only needs to cover $45,000, so the FIRE target drops from $1.5 million to $1.125 million at a 4% withdrawal rate. Discount that back to today at your assumed real return over the years until retirement, and that is your Coast FIRE number.
Worked through: you are 35, you plan to retire at 60, and you assume a 5% real return over the 25 years in between. $1.05 raised to the 25th is about 3.39. Without rental income, $1.5 million divided by 3.39 gives a Coast FIRE number near $443,000. With the $15,000 of rental income, $1.125 million divided by 3.39 gives about $332,000. The rental property saves you roughly $111,000 of portfolio today. To run your own version, enter your reduced spending in the Coast FIRE calculator rather than adding anything to your savings.
How rental income changes your Coast FIRE number
The critical word is net. Count rental income after the mortgage payment, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancies, and a reserve for big repairs, not the rent check. A property renting for $1,800 a month with a $1,100 mortgage payment and $200 in monthly taxes and insurance grosses $21,600 a year but nets something like $4,000 to $6,000 once reality takes its cut. Most people who believe rental income closes their Coast FIRE gap are counting gross rent. Do the net math first, on paper, with the ugly line items included.
And do not add the property's value to the number. Your Coast FIRE number counts invested assets that compound untouched until retirement. Equity in a rental is not compounding inside your portfolio; its contribution arrives as the income stream, which you already counted above. Counting both the equity and the income is double counting. (The same logic is why home equity stays out of the number.)
One more use for the two numbers: the gap between them is your stress test. If the $332,000 figure assumes the rental and the $443,000 figure does not, then $443,000 is the number that holds when the property sits vacant for six months or the roof goes. I like knowing both. The rental-adjusted number is the plan; the unadjusted number is the plan's backup.
Here is the honest tension, and I will not resolve it for you. The spreadsheet treats $15,000 of rental income as a bond coupon. It is not. Tenants leave, roofs fail, and one bad eviction can erase a year of net income. Rental income is a part-time job wearing an income stream's clothes, which sits oddly inside Coast FIRE, a philosophy about buying back your time. My rule: haircut rental income by 25%, and never let the plan depend on it at full strength. If the math only works with the rent at 100% and the property fully occupied, the plan is fragile no matter what the number says.
So count it, on the spending side, net of everything, haircut for reality. Then the number is smaller and the plan is honest, which is the entire point of calculating it in the first place.
Already hit your number?
Check your Coast FIRE status with your own savings, expenses, and growth rate.
Calculate My Coast FIRE NumberFrequently asked questions
Should I count gross rent or net rental income toward Coast FIRE?
Net, always. Subtract the mortgage payment, taxes, insurance, maintenance, a vacancy allowance, and a reserve for major repairs. Gross rent overstates the income by a wide margin on most properties.
Does the rental property's value count toward my Coast FIRE number?
No. The number measures invested assets compounding untouched until retirement. Count the income stream or the equity, never both; counting both is double counting.
What if I plan to sell the rental before I retire?
Then count the expected after-tax sale proceeds as part of your portfolio, not as ongoing income. Pick one treatment and stick with it.
How much should I haircut rental income in my Coast FIRE math?
A 20 to 25% haircut for vacancies and capital expenses is a reasonable cushion. Older properties and thin cash reserves argue for a bigger one.
Related reading: Does Home Equity Count Toward Your Coast FIRE Number? · Coast FIRE Formula: How to Calculate Your Number by Hand · How Much Part-Time Income Do You Need to Coast FIRE?
One practical FIRE note a month: subscribe on Substack.