Here is the seductive part, so we are honest about what we are arguing with. A 35-year-old targeting $1 million in today's dollars at age 65 has 30 years of compounding ahead. At 7 percent real, the Coast FIRE number is about $131,000. At a more cautious 5 percent real, it is about $231,000. One deposit, no more contributions, and the math carries you home. Honestly, a spreadsheet telling you that you are done at 35 should scare you a little, because the number is a forecast wearing a promise's clothes.
Now the part most warnings get wrong. With no contributions and no withdrawals, the order of returns does not change the final number. Multiplication commutes: a 40 percent crash in year 2, followed by a recovery strong enough to preserve the assumed 30-year average, lands at exactly $1 million, same as the smooth path. Run it yourself and the arithmetic agrees. So when people say "a crash early in your coasting period disrupts compounding," the crash is not the mechanism. The mechanism is everything the sentence leaves out.
The three things that actually break the plan
First, the average does not survive the crash. The math above required 7.1 percent real for 28 straight years after the crash to keep the 30-year average intact. That recovery is the heroic assumption, not the crash. Real bear markets are often followed by good years, but "good enough to fully repair a 40 percent hole on schedule" is a much stronger claim than "markets recover." If post-crash returns merely match your original assumption instead of exceeding it, you land short, and short by a lot: the crashed portfolio, about $146,000 after the 40 percent drop, growing at 5 percent real for the remaining 28 years reaches roughly $571,000, not $1 million.
Second, forced selling. The commutation argument assumes no cash flows, and life does not cooperate. A market crash and a job loss are correlated events: the same recession that halves your portfolio can take your income. If you sell investments to live during the downturn, order suddenly matters enormously, because shares sold at the bottom never participate in the recovery. This is why the standard advice pairs the Coast number with a cash buffer of several months of expenses, kept outside the invested portfolio. The buffer is not about returns. It is about never becoming a forced seller.
Third, behavior. Crashes cause derisking at the bottom. The coaster who shifts to bonds after watching a third of the portfolio evaporate has locked in lower expected returns for the remaining decades, which is a slow-motion version of the crash itself, except this one is voluntary. Shifting conservative too early is the mistake the spreadsheet cannot warn you about, because the spreadsheet assumes you hold the allocation for 30 years without flinching.
What actually protects a coasting plan
Four things, in order of how much they help. Run the number at 5 percent real instead of 7, which lifts the required starting amount by about three-quarters, and then add a 20 to 30 percent buffer on top. Yes, that makes the number much bigger. That is the point. The buffer is not pessimism; it is the price of the one assumption you cannot control. Recheck the number yearly instead of filing it away: finding out in year 3 that a bad stretch pushed you behind beats finding out in year 25. Decide your escape hatches in advance, resume contributions, push the retirement age out, pick up part-time work that covers expenses, or trim the spending target, because people who decide these in calm years execute them in bad ones. And keep the portfolio aggressive enough to earn the return the number assumes, with the cash buffer standing guard so a rough patch in working income never forces a sale.
The spreadsheet is not lying. It is just answering a narrower question than the one you asked. It tells you what happens if the average holds and nothing moves. Your job is everything else: the buffer for when the average does not hold, the cash for when life does not cooperate, and the written plan for the year the market tests whether you meant it.
What is sequence of returns risk in Coast FIRE?
It is the danger that poor returns early in the coasting period leave you short of your number. Strictly speaking, with zero contributions and zero withdrawals, return order does not change the final value: multiplication commutes. The real risk is everything around the math: the long-run average failing to materialize, forced selling during a downturn, and derisking at the bottom.
Does the order of returns really not matter for Coast FIRE?
As pure math, with no cash flowing in or out, it does not: a 40 percent crash in year 2 followed by strong enough recovery to preserve the assumed 30-year average lands at exactly the target. But that recovery assumption is the heroic part, and any withdrawals during the crash, like selling investments after a job loss, make order matter enormously.
How big a buffer should I add to my Coast FIRE number?
A common rule of thumb is 20 to 30 percent above the calculated number, alongside flexibility on your retirement age. Another approach is to run the math at 5 percent real instead of 7 percent, which lifts the required starting amount by about three-quarters and builds the margin in directly.
What are the escape hatches if my Coast FIRE number falls behind?
Resume contributions, even small ones; push the retirement age out a few years; pick up part-time work that covers expenses; or trim the retirement spending target. Decide these in calm years so you can execute them in bad ones, and recheck the number yearly.
Should I keep my portfolio aggressive during the coasting phase?
Mostly yes, because the math depends on decades of equity compounding, and shifting conservative too early drags returns below what the number assumes. Keep a separate cash buffer of a few months of expenses so a rough patch in your working income never forces you to sell investments at the bottom.
Related reading: What Growth Rate Should You Actually Use? · Is Coast FIRE Real? The Criticism, and the Honest Answer · Your Coast FIRE Number by Age · Can You Coast FIRE with $200K Saved?
One FIRE note a week: subscribe to the newsletter.